How Much Do Car Insurance Costs Increase After an Accident?

April 14, 2021 | Attorney, Matthew Dolman
How Much Do Car Insurance Costs Increase After an Accident? Car Accident Attorney, Matt Dolman

Car Insurance Increases After a Car Accident

In a single year, more than 402,500 car accidents took place in Florida. The vast majority of these car accidents resulted in significant property damage. In addition, many of them involved serious injury or death to one or more of the vehicle's occupants. Often, after being involved in a car accident, people question, “How much will my car insurance payment increase?” The answer to this question will vary depending on the specific facts of your case. Several factors will determine how much your insurance premiums will increase. How severe was the accident? Were you at fault? Where did the accident occur? Read on for more information about car insurance and post-accident increases. A car accident lawyer can also answer your questions and help you seek the compensation you need to pay for those increased premiums.

Where You Live Can Affect Your Insurance

Although not necessarily a cause of increased insurance rates after an accident, where you live affects the costs of insurance rates. According to a news report from the Ledger, nationally, Florida has some of the most expensive car insurance rates. On average Americans pay $1,470 each year for car insurance. In Florida, on the other hand, the average annual rate for car insurance is $2,059. The rates have increased more than 50 percent since 2011. Further, Florida residents in certain ZIP codes may pay even more for their insurance than other places within the state. Urban residents pay up to three times more for insurance than those living in rural areas. Drivers living within Miami ZIP codes can expect to pay, on average, over $3,000 a year for car insurance. Higher car insurance rates in Florida, in part, can be attributed to the requirement that drivers purchase a personal injury protection (PIP) policy. Additionally, rates are higher because Florida ranks among the worst in numbers of uninsured drivers. In 2017, the Insurance Research Council reported that Florida's PIP claims were almost 50 percent higher than anywhere else in the nation. Additionally, 37 percent of claimants undergo MRIs. That is double the number of individuals receiving these diagnostic imaging tests in other parts of the country. The report also noted that 53 percent of claimants hire an attorney. A surprising amount considering that all Florida vehicle owners are required to purchase a PIP policy. PIP policies are intended to drive down the legal costs associated with compensation.

Were You At Fault for the Car Accident?

Car Accident Injury CostsAfter one at-fault accident causing more than $2,000 in damages, car insurance rates are expected to increase by about 31 percent. That equates to an increase of around $450 a year. Drivers who cause an accident that results in bodily injury can expect to pay slightly more. Accidents causing injury may increase insurance rates by 32 percent. A 32 percent increase will equate to around $459 a year. A second at-fault accident with property damage equaling over $2,000 can cause the price you pay for insurance to increase significantly. You may expect your rates to go up by about 110 percent, or $1,572. Keep in mind, however, that these numbers are national averages. The amount your rate will increase after an accident or multiple accidents will ultimately depend on the terms of the insurance agreement. The specific personal or property damages resulting from the accident will also influence the amount rates are increased. Increases ranging from 12 percent to 80 percent can be expected, depending on the severity of the accident and the company's agreement. Some companies offer accident forgiveness for your first accident. Accident forgiveness will prevent your rates from going up, though you may become ineligible for any “good driver” discounts.

Florida Insurance Rate Increases

In Florida, the rates of increase are higher than the national average. After one at-fault accident with property damage over $2,000, Florida driver's rates are expected to increase by about 35 percent. A 35 percent increase equates to around $795 a year. If you were impaired by alcohol at the time of the accident, insurance increases can be even higher. A DUI conviction can cause insurance increases of three to five times more compared to drivers with a clean driving record. With a DUI charge, the higher insurance rates may be imposed against the driver for three years or more. What if the accident wasn't your fault? Some insurance companies will raise your rates anyway, particularly if you've had multiple accidents. They may even raise the rates if you were not at fault for any accident you were in. In fact, getting into multiple accidents—regardless of fault—could result in your insurance company completely dropping you from coverage.

How Are Increases Calculated After an Accident?

Insurance companies set a base rate for the individuals they insure. The base rate is calculated depending on the average rates in your area, minus any eligible discounts. After filing an accident claim, your insurance company will generally employ a surcharge schedule to determine the amount of increase. Standards set by the Insurance Services Office allow for a surcharge of 20 percent to 40 percent of the insurer's base rate. If you have a single-car policy, the surcharge will be 40 percent of the base. For a multi-car policy, the surcharge will be 20 percent of the base rate for the first two vehicles listed on the policy. The surcharge added to your rate includes other costs and fees. It may include costs of the claims adjuster, fees paid to claims representatives, and the costs of parts and labor. The surcharge and applicable fees will only be added to your premium after a claim is filed.

What Is Your Driving History?

Even if your driving record has improved, your past driving history can come back to haunt you. Insurance companies conduct a risk assessment on all drivers who are applying for insurance coverage. Part of this risk assessment includes evaluating a summary of your driving record for the past three years or more. In evaluating your driving record, drivers are categorized as low-risk (standard) or high-risk (substandard). The following can result in a higher premium payments:
  • Multiple accidents;
  • Multiple traffic infractions;
  • Any traffic- or accident-related criminal convictions, including the failure to appear in court over a traffic offense;
  • Any license restrictions, such as being prohibited from driving at night due to poor eyesight;
  • Any license suspensions or revocations occurring within the look-back period;
  • A low credit score, as insurance companies see a correlation between poor credit and poor driving practices; and
  • Moving violations, including speeding, reckless driving, or DUI, which can also make your health and life insurance premiums increase.

How Long Will the Higher Rates Last?

Car Insurance The penalty period in which you're paying higher premiums due to an accident usually lasts three to five years. The time period coincides with the time in which the accident will be removed from your motor vehicle record summary. However, your policy may not be set to renew for many months after the penalty period for your accident ends. In that case, you will continue to pay the higher rate until the renewal takes place. Insurance companies only recalculate rates when they are scheduled to be renewed. Other factors may extend the penalty period, including:
  • DUI conviction;
  • Bodily injury claims;
  • Reckless driving;
  • An accident resulting in serious bodily injury or death; or
  • Excessive tickets or accident claims within a specific period of time.

What Is Your Gender? Are You Married? What Kind of Car Do You Drive?

According to The Ledger report, other factors may influence the amount your car insurance will increase. For example, women pay slightly higher rates for insurance than men do. Overall, the difference is less than 1 percent; however, in Nevada, it is as high as 6 percent. Married couples typically pay less for insurance than singles do. Additionally, your rates may be higher based on your level of education. Aside from accident history or DUIs, one of the sharpest increases in insurance rates often occurs when you change vehicles. Truck owners may pay as much as $500 more per year than car drivers. Newer model vehicles are also more expensive to insure. The report notes that the Audi R8 is among the most expensive cars to insure, costing owners more than $4,000 per year.

Can You Reduce the Amount You Pay for Insurance?

Unfortunately, there is not much you can do about a negative driving history and its impact on your insurance in the short term. However, there are ways you can decrease your premiums over time, including:
  • Bundle all of your insurance policies—auto, home, and life insurance—with one company. Typically, companies offer discounts for insureds who bundle their policies. You can also save money by insuring multiple vehicles and multiple drivers in one policy.
  • Increase your deductible. Many drivers pay lower premiums in exchange for paying a higher deductible when they make a claim. Remember, if you choose this option, your coverage may not be as good. With poor coverage, you will be responsible for paying a lot more when you file a claim. If you choose to increase your deductible, you should keep the amount of the deductible in an interest-bearing savings account. This way, the funds are available if you should need them and you won't be stranded when the unexpected happens.
  • When accident damages are less than the amount of your deductible, it is recommended that you pay to fix the damage yourself. Keeping the claim off your insurance history may keep your rates lower. However, not filing a claim doesn't mean that you shouldn't report the accident to your insurance company. Most insurance policies require the driver to report all accidents. Make sure your insurance representative places a note in your file indicating you are not planning to file a claim.
  • Improve your credit score by decreasing your amount of debt.
  • Insuring a teenage driver will cause your insurance premiums to go up. However, you can usually obtain a discount if your young driver maintains at least a B average in school.
  • Drive carefully to avoid accidents and moving violations that can drive your costs up. In time, your past driving infractions will fall off the insurance motor vehicle lookback period. After the lookback period expires, you may qualify for increased savings.
  • Check with your insurance company to find out if they offer discounts to drivers who take a defensive driving course. In addition to saving money, you may also learn some new skills that can help make you safer on the roadway. Safer driving will result in fewer accidents, which can lower your premium rates.
  • Pay your policy in full rather than in monthly installments. Most insurance companies offer a discount for drivers who pay the costs of insurance in a lump sum.
  • Shop around. As previously mentioned, insurance company rates and allowances they offer can vary widely from company to company. If you're planning to change companies, it helps to compare quotes from multiple companies. You should also ask family and friends who they're covered by and what they like about their auto insurance company.

What Not to Do to Avoid Insurance Increase

Even though possible increases in insurance rates are intimidating, it is never a good idea to drive without insurance. Uninsured drivers are potentially responsible for a range of expenses. Uninsured drivers have to pay out of pocket for their own vehicle repairs. Additionally, you may face the costs of a lawsuit if you are sued by the other driver. If the lawsuit is successful, you may be responsible for all injuries and expenses caused by the accident. Driving without insurance in Florida may result in a fine of up to $500. Depending on the number of offenses you have, your license, registration, and license plates may all be suspended. If you get sued for the accident, suspensions may remain in effect until you pay the entire cost of damages.

Seek an Experienced Clearwater Car Accident Lawyer

If you were injured in a car accident, a car accident lawyer can help you understand the legal processes for seeking compensation. If you're facing increased insurance premiums, your car accident attorney may take that into account when calculating and fighting to recover damages on your behalf. Dolman Law Group Accident Injury Lawyers, PA 800 North Belcher Road Clearwater, FL 33765 (727) 451-6900


Matthew Dolman

Personal Injury Lawyer

This article was written and reviewed by Matthew Dolman. Matt has been a practicing civil trial, personal injury, products liability, and mass tort lawyer since 2004. He has successfully fought for more than 11,000 injured clients and acted as lead counsel in more than 1,000 lawsuits. Always on the cutting edge of personal injury law, Matt is actively engaged in complex legal matters, including Suboxone, AFFF, and Ozempic lawsuits.  Matt is a lifetime member of the Million Dollar Advocates Forum and Multi-Million Dollar Advocates Forum for resolving individual cases in excess of $1 million and $2 million, respectively. He has also been selected by his colleagues as a Florida Superlawyer and as a member of Florida’s Legal Elite on multiple occasions. Further, Matt has been quoted in the media numerous times and is a sought-after speaker on a variety of legal issues and topics.

Learn More